New in Box Taken out for photos only I have checked tips on pencils both tips are intact. LimeLife By Alcone ~ Enduring Gel Eyeliner Pencil Duo Shade: # 4 Work Hard/PlayHard The long-wear formula lasts up to 24 hours for a waterproof, smudge-proof look. Item ships within one Business day after payment is received. NOTE: Due to this being a beauty product I can not accept returns on this item.